1172 Shares

Alexander Hamilton's Federalist Papers - could someone help with this quote?

Alexander Hamilton's Federalist Papers - could someone help with this quote? Topic: Helped write the federalist papers
May 25, 2019 / By Harrietta
Question: "They would contain various exceptions to powers which are not granted; and on this very account, would afford a colorable pretext to claim more than were granted. For why declare that things shall not be done which there is no power to do?" I know it's supposed to be about how by making exceptions to a rule, people could actually have less rights because they wouldn't be able to dispute the whole rule as easily. I think. xD I "translated" the last sentence as "What is the point of saying that someone shouldn’t do something because that power isn’t given?" but am still very confused about its intended meaning. Would someone mind basically "translating"/explaining the quote for me to make it more understandable? Thanks in advance!
Best Answer

Best Answers: Alexander Hamilton's Federalist Papers - could someone help with this quote?

Donelle Donelle | 5 days ago
This was taken from Hamilton's argument against a Bill of Rights. His argument, put briefly was that by specifying rights it might be construed that people have only the rights specified, and further, that it would open the door to regulate rights when no power to regulate them currently exists. When he writes..."For why declare that things shall not be done which there is no power to do?" He's saying just that. He saying that specifying rights can open the door (which he believes is currently closed) to future regulation by the state. That's why he continues with the example of regulating the press. "Why for instance, should it be said, that the liberty of the press shall not be restrained, when no power is given by which restrictions may be imposed?" Hope this helps.
👍 218 | 👎 5
Did you like the answer? Alexander Hamilton's Federalist Papers - could someone help with this quote? Share with your friends

We found more questions related to the topic: Helped write the federalist papers


Donelle Originally Answered: What are the negatives to alexander hamilton's views?
you could argue that Alexander Hamilton needed desperately for the united statesA. to be a ecu autocracy and not using a divinely appointed monarch. He became into for great government, ordinary taxing authority, a standing military, a life-time Presidential term, lifetime Senatorial words, and a centralized national financial business enterprise. In sum, Hamilton became into an effeminate elitist liberal who had no admire for difficult working farmers and homesteaders.

Caryn Caryn
humorous difficulty. Jefferson replaced into no longer between the Framers of the form. that would advise extra if he were considered one of those gents interior the room hammering out and debating the form. playstation ....Jefferson additionally wrote ""No unfastened guy shall ever be debarred using hands. The maximum efficient rationalization for the folk to preserve the only right to maintain and submit to hands is, as a final hotel, to guard themselves against tyranny in government" You your self in many circumstances ask the question the place does it say interior the 2d substitute that it quite is approximately resisting government tyranny. properly, previous TJ pronounced that's what it quite is for! So it quite is it? can we believe previous TJ on those themes, or no longer? I for one am effective with separation of church and state. replace: As endured scripting this answer, i found out that. i'm actual taking the two factors in this answer.
👍 90 | 👎 -4

Caryn Originally Answered: What did alexander hamilton contribute to our nation?
Hamilton created the Federalist Party and dominated it until 1800. It was the first political party in the nation; some have called it the first mass-based party in any republic; others have seen its chief weakness in having too little connection to the masses. As early as 1790, Hamilton started putting together a nationwide coalition, using the contacts he had made in the Army and the Treasury, building vocal political support in each state by signing up prominent men who were like-minded nationalists. The friends of the government especially included merchants, bankers, and financiers in a dozen major cities. By 1792 or 1793 newspapers started calling Hamilton supporters "Federalists" and the opponents "democrats" or "republicans". Religious and educational leaders, hostile to the French Revolution, joined his coalition, especially in New England. Hamilton systematically set up a Federalist newspaper network, recruiting and subsidizing editors including Noah Webster and John Fenno; he wrote numerous anonymous editorials and essays for his papers.
Caryn Originally Answered: What did alexander hamilton contribute to our nation?
He was Washington's chief second during the Revolution. He got the Constitution pass in New York and housed President Washington there. He was the first secretary of the Treasury and created America's first economic policies.

If you have your own answer to the question helped write the federalist papers, then you can write your own version, using the form below for an extended answer.