4096 Shares

Serious question of my fellow Catholics: Why does the Church no longer allow married women to retire and enter?

Serious question of my fellow Catholics: Why does the Church no longer allow married women to retire and enter? Topic: Order of the sister wives
July 21, 2019 / By Flora
Question: a convent? In the past it was common practice for some wives to reach an agreement with their husbands and enter religious life, why is this no longer permitted? I have a few divorced friends who have no desire to remarry but would love to enter an Order. Please help me explain this to them.
Best Answer

Best Answers: Serious question of my fellow Catholics: Why does the Church no longer allow married women to retire and enter?

Dalia Dalia | 1 day ago
First of all there is a loss of vocations and this would be good for many orders. However with retirement and money as it is they need people who can provide funds for their own living expenses. I know it sound lousy but that is the reason for not allowing entrance. They do not have the funds to keep the elderly sisters/nuns right now and many people used to support the orders, but now they don't. Medical, food, clothing ( when they came out of the habit they need clothes to wear and this has become a big expense where they used to make their own habits) and housing. Many have gone out on their own and rented an apartment and are still in the order. It comes down to monetary problems. God bless you. And daver is correct about divorce, they would have to get permission from their ex's in order to enter, for in the eyes of God they are still married, if they married in the church. Now the thumbs down on this question is not necessary, so why did we get them. Go figure!!! Someone doesn't like these answers.
👍 170 | 👎 1
Did you like the answer? Serious question of my fellow Catholics: Why does the Church no longer allow married women to retire and enter? Share with your friends

We found more questions related to the topic: Order of the sister wives


Dalia Originally Answered: This is a question for married women.?
First I want to commend you for going to the doctor. Most men are a liitle touchy about that kind of thing. Your wife should realize the lengths you went to to satisfy her needs. There are meds and creams for her as well. Its a two way street. Every woman in the world has had times where she just wasn't in the mood.....BUT..... for the sake of their man took care of them in one way or the other.Communication is a very important aspect of your marriage. Talk to her.I'm sure a part of her will worry about her little porn star laying next to her unsatisfied will not only bother her but worry her. My husband and I have a long running joke, If you can't get it at home............Good luck.

Blanda Blanda
Priests not being allowed to marry was started sometime in the 1500's the first Priests and Popes of the Catholic church were married. The Catholic Church changed the law when they realized married Priests left their wealth to their families instead of the Church.
👍 70 | 👎 -8

Ainslie Ainslie
Husband and wife would have to BOTH enter orders, not just the wife. Your divorced friends can enter IF they have their marriages declared null. Otherwise, they are still obliged to their ex-spouses in a spiritual way. Some orders cannot accept older women because of the nature of the lifestyle. Some cloistered orders, for example, find that older ladies cannot adapt well, and so they encourage them to seek a different type of order. Another option is Total Consecration.
👍 70 | 👎 -17

Tony Tony
I've heard they still can, if the husband also wants to enter a religious order or become a priest. That was several years ago that I head that, though. I'm not sure if it still applies. These days, the Church gives out annulments much more easily than in the past, so maybe that has something to do with it. Maybe the marriage must be annulled first. That's just a guess, though. Dave
👍 70 | 👎 -26

Read Read
Specific to your friends who are divorced, the Church does not acknowledge a divorce as binding because divorce is a mere legal procedure with no bearing on the Holy Sacrament of Matrimony. A "divorced" person is still married in the eyes of the Church, and a divorce can't constitute a "retiring" from a marriage.
👍 70 | 👎 -35

Read Originally Answered: Fellow Socially Liberal Catholics: Doesn't this make you proud?
While I don't think the Church will ever accept gay marriage as sacramental (for to do so would directly contradict the Bible) I think it is essential that it be allowed as legal. To not allow it to be legal would be an infringement on free will in cases where no unwilling participants are adversely effected. For me, I think it shows that many religious Catholics are trying to follow the words of the Catechism and Jesus message of love: "[Homosexuals] must be accepted with respect, compassion, and sensitivity. Every sign of unjust discrimination in their regard should be avoided."

If you have your own answer to the question order of the sister wives, then you can write your own version, using the form below for an extended answer.